GTA 6's Metacritic Review Bomb Is the Fourth Time We've Run This Experiment
The user score on Grand Theft Auto 6's Metacritic page is not a review of Grand Theft Auto 6. It is a turnout number.
Forbes reported on November 21 that the game is being review bombed on Metacritic. GAMINGbible, meanwhile, notes that fans are circulating lists of what they describe as every "legitimate" complaint, even as the game sits in the Game of the Year conversation. Both things are true at once, and neither is new.
We have run this exact experiment three times in the past decade, and the results are consistent enough to be useful: the week-one user score tells you almost nothing about the game and a great deal about who is angry and why. The trick is knowing which kind of anger you're looking at.
What Metacritic actually measures
Worth restating, because the two numbers on the page get conflated constantly. Visual Capitalist's ranking of the highest-rated video games of all time is compiled from Metacritic — and every game on that list is there on the strength of the critic aggregate. The user score is a separate instrument sitting on the same page, built on a different method: no proof of purchase, no minimum playtime, no rate limit worth the name.
That is not a flaw someone forgot to fix. It is a design choice that has survived three separate controversies.
The first time: Grand Theft Auto: The Trilogy — The Definitive Edition (2021)
The closest precedent is the one in the same house. When Rockstar shipped the Definitive Edition in November 2021, the user score collapsed within hours — and this time the complaints were about the product itself: the ports, the visuals, the bugs. Rockstar apologized publicly, restored the original trilogy to digital storefronts, and spent months patching.
What followed is the part people forget. The apology landed in days. The fixes took far longer. The user score never really recovered, but the underlying problem did get solved, quietly, by engineers rather than by statements.
Lesson one: a bomb aimed at a real defect is a leading indicator. It is loud, ugly, and roughly accurate.
The second time: The Last of Us Part II (2020)
Within days of release, the user score was being driven down by people objecting not to how the game played but to what happens in it. The volume was enormous, and many of the reviews were written before anyone could plausibly have finished the game.
Metacritic's response was procedural, not editorial: it introduced a waiting period before user reviews could be submitted. That is the platform's whole playbook — add friction, decline to adjudicate.
And commercially, the bomb did nothing. The game went on to win Game of the Year awards and sell in enormous numbers. The user score is still low. Both facts coexist on the same internet.
Lesson two: a bomb aimed at a story decision is a poll, not a review. It measures a culture argument that happens to be hosted on a games site.
The third time: Cyberpunk 2077 (2020)
Six months after The Last of Us Part II, CD Projekt Red shipped Cyberpunk 2077 and the user score cratered — this time because the console versions genuinely did not work. Critics had reviewed on PC. Players had bought on PlayStation 4 and Xbox One. The gap between the two scores was the most honest chart in gaming that month.
The repair took years. The game was eventually rebuilt, and by the time the 2.0 update and Phantom Liberty arrived in 2023, the narrative had flipped. The user score from December 2020 is still sitting there, memorializing a version of the game that no longer exists.
Lesson three: when the complaint is real, the score is a symptom that outlives its cause. That is the failure mode that matters most — the internet does not update its verdicts.
So which one is this?
That is the only question worth asking about GTA 6, and it cannot be answered in week one. The signals to watch are concrete.
- Does Rockstar patch? A substantive patch inside the first 30 days means the complaints had product substance — the Trilogy pattern. Silence, or a statement without a build behind it, points the other way.
- Does the distribution have a shape? A real defect produces a cluster: many low scores, many high ones, a hole in the middle. A campaign produces a spike at zero and a flat line everywhere else.
- Does Take-Two say anything? GTA is the company's balance sheet. Watch the next earnings call and the language around engagement and bookings, not the Metacritic page.
And note what the Federal Trade Commission cannot do here. Its rule against fake reviews and testimonials, in effect since 2024, targets purchased and fabricated reviews. It has nothing to say about ten thousand real people with real grudges. Review bombing is not fraud; it is a mob, and mobs are legal.
What actually happened the last three times
In all three cases, the launch user score was a poor predictor of quality and a decent predictor of grievance. With Cyberpunk, the grievance was accurate and the score was simply early. With The Last of Us Part II, the grievance was about narrative and the score was irrelevant. With the GTA Trilogy, the grievance was accurate, Rockstar fixed the product, and the number stayed broken anyway.
Notice the pattern in the aftermath: not one of these was resolved by a review, a statement, or a counter-campaign. Every one was resolved, or not, by the people who make the thing.
For the reader, the practical version is short. Ignore the user score for ten days. Then look at the shape of the distribution rather than the average. Then read the three-star reviews, which are the only ones written by people who finished the game and came away with mixed feelings.
And keep one thing in mind before you treat any of this as a verdict: the games on Visual Capitalist's all-time list got there on critic scores, and the games that got review bombed got there on volume. Only one of those numbers requires you to have played anything.
Common questions
Is Grand Theft Auto 6 actually being review bombed on Metacritic?
Forbes reported on November 21 that GTA 6 is being review bombed on Metacritic, and GAMINGbible reported that fans are circulating lists of what they call legitimate complaints while the game remains in Game of the Year discussion. Neither outlet published a verified count of how many of the negative user reviews came from people who played the game.
Why does Metacritic's user score differ so much from the critic score?
They are two separate instruments. The critic score requires an assigned outlet and a published review. The user score requires only an account — there is no proof of purchase and no minimum playtime. That is why Visual Capitalist's ranking of the highest-rated games of all time is built on the critic aggregate rather than the user one.
Has review bombing ever actually changed a game?
Yes, but only when the complaints were about the product. The GTA Trilogy Definitive Edition in 2021 and Cyberpunk 2077 in 2020 both drew scores that tracked real defects, and both were eventually fixed by patches rather than by statements. The Last of Us Part II in 2020 drew a bomb over story decisions, and it changed nothing commercially.
Should I trust the GTA 6 user score when deciding whether to buy it?
Not in the first ten days. Wait for the distribution to settle, then look at whether the low scores are clustered (a real defect) or spiked at zero (a campaign). The three-star reviews are usually the most informative, because they tend to come from people who actually finished the game.