Ja'Marr Chase and the Flag That Wasn't: The NFL Has Fixed This Three Times, and It Never Sticks
Cris Collinsworth said on the broadcast that officials missed an end-zone hold on Ja'Marr Chase, and by the time the white-out crowd filed out, the argument had already migrated to the wrong question. Whether it was a hold is unanswerable and, more importantly, unactionable. The question that actually has an answer is what the NFL does with a nationally televised no-call, because we have three clean case studies from the last twenty years, and they all end the same way: a rule gets written, the team that got hurt still loses, and the fix is repealed or hollowed out within a few seasons.
That is not a knock on Collinsworth. It is the mechanism. A former Bengals receiver, working the biggest window on the league's schedule, narrating a penalty he believes was missed against his old team's best player, is precisely how a no-call becomes a story the league has to respond to. The broadcast booth is the amplifier. The competition committee is the response. The scoreboard is never the response.
Strip the names off today's grievance and the structure is identical to three earlier cases: a penalty that wasn't called in a high-leverage moment, on national television, involving a player the audience can identify by silhouette. Here is what happened the last three times.
2006: The hit that got a rule named after it
This one is not a no-call, but it is the founding document of the Bengals-Steelers prime-time grievance genre. On Jan. 8, 2006, in the wild-card round at Paul Brown Stadium, Carson Palmer's second throw of the game ended with a torn knee ligament after a low hit from Steelers defensive lineman Kimo von Oelhoffen. Pittsburgh won that day and went on to win Super Bowl XL.
The league's answer arrived months later, in the form of a rule barring hits at or below the knee on a passer standing in the pocket. Everyone called it the Carson Palmer rule. It protected every quarterback who came after Palmer. It did not give Palmer that afternoon back, and it did not give the Bengals that playoff game back.
2012: The Fail Mary and the fastest fix in league history
On Sept. 24, 2012, replacement officials working a Monday night game in Seattle awarded Golden Tate a contested touchdown against Green Bay. The play went to replay review and the ruling stood. Within days, the league reached a deal with its locked-out referees, and the regular crews were back the following weekend.
Note what the fix actually was: a labor settlement. The league bought competence, not reviewability. It did not make judgment calls at the goal line subject to challenge; it did not rewrite the simultaneous-catch rule that produced the confusion. Green Bay still carried a loss that shaped its playoff seeding. The lesson the league took was that the problem was staffing, and staffing is a checkbook problem.
2019: The no-call that made pass interference reviewable for exactly one season
This is the closest match to today. In the NFC Championship in January 2019, Rams cornerback Nickell Robey-Coleman hit Saints receiver Tommylee Lewis early and high on a play that would have iced the game. No flag. New Orleans kicked a field goal, lost in overtime, and did not go to the Super Bowl.
The reaction included a lawsuit from the Saints' season-ticket holders. The owners' response, voted through that March, made pass interference — and only pass interference — reviewable, on a one-year trial. Coaches challenged; reversals were scarce; the experiment expired quietly after the 2019 season and was not renewed.
The pattern is the point
Three grievances, three remedies, one shape. The remedy is always procedural, never retrospective. Nobody replays a game, nobody un-loses a Super Bowl berth, nobody re-scores a play. The remedy always arrives months later and benefits a stranger. And the remedy always shrinks: the low-hit rule survives but is enforced inconsistently, the interference review died after a single season, and the officiating deal solved a staffing crisis while leaving judgment exactly where it was.
The team on the wrong end pays immediately and permanently. That is the entire history of this in three sentences.
Why holding will not become reviewable
Holding is the least reviewable foul in football and the most frequently committed one, which are related facts. Offensive and defensive players hand-fight on nearly every passing down; a flag on one end-zone rep and silence on the next is a consistency problem, not a technology problem. There is no camera angle that settles holding, and the league has spent the years since 2019 shrinking replay rather than expanding it.
There is also a procedural wall. A coach cannot challenge a no-call, and the only formal channel for a missed flag is the league's internal grading of officials — a private process that affects a crew's postseason assignments and produces, at most, a phone call to the head coach a day or two later. Collinsworth's comment creates pressure on that process. It does not create a remedy inside it.
What to watch now, and what to do with it
Watch the competition committee's spring agenda, not the Monday headlines. If a Bengals-Steelers end-zone no-call produces anything at all, it will arrive as a narrowly written proposal on defensive holding inside the 5-yard line, it will get tabled once the owners see the enforcement math, and it will be quietly dead by summer. That is the historical hit rate.
Watch for the private acknowledgment. The league's standard move after a high-profile miss is a call to the affected coach during the week — an apology that functions as an admission and changes nothing, because no result is reopenable.
And if you have money on this game, understand the settlement rule. Props on Chase — his catches, his yardage, whether he scores — settle on the official stat sheet, and a missed flag is not a statistic. Nothing gets re-scored, nothing gets voided, and no sportsbook adjusts a ticket because a broadcaster was right. That is why the betting markets, including ESPN's Week 10 board for this game, price the players and not the officiating: the stat sheet is the settlement, and the stat sheet does not care what the booth saw.
The most useful thing a US reader can take from tonight is not outrage but expectation. The NFL will respond to this exactly as it responded in 2006, 2012 and 2019 — with a rule that protects the next player in the next game, and not the one who just got held in the end zone.
Common questions
Did officials miss a hold on Ja'Marr Chase?
Cris Collinsworth said on the Sunday Night Football broadcast that officials missed an end-zone hold on Chase, according to the Cincinnati Enquirer. The comment was prompted by the absence of a flag on the play. The NFL does not issue in-game statements on specific calls; its usual practice is to address them privately with the team during the following week.
Can the play be reviewed or the result changed?
No. Holding is not a reviewable foul, and coaches cannot challenge a no-call. The league's one-year experiment with reviewable pass interference, adopted in 2019, applied only to interference and was not renewed after that season.
What is the closest historical precedent?
The missed pass interference call in the January 2019 NFC Championship between the Rams and Saints. It produced a rule making pass interference reviewable for one season, almost no overturned calls, and no change to the outcome of the game.
Do missed penalties affect betting props?
No. Player props such as Chase's catches and receiving yards settle on the official stat sheet. A penalty that wasn't called does not alter a statistic, so no ticket is re-scored or voided.