counter hit make
Trending

Trending

Hailey Bieber's First Windbreaker Is the Smallest Version of a Bet That Has Failed Three Times

4 min read

Everyone is searching. Almost nobody is reading past the headline.
Everyone is searching. Almost nobody is reading past the headline.

The most revealing thing about Rhode's first piece of clothing is that it is a windbreaker. Not a runway, not a full line, not a dress with a waitlist. A single navy outerwear piece, released as a capsule to mark Hailey Bieber's 30th birthday — that is how Hypebae, Yahoo and the London Evening Standard all describe it.

The restraint is not timidity. It is the shape the celebrity-beauty industry settled on after watching three of its biggest names walk into apparel and get hurt. Rhode is not doing something new. Rhode is doing the smallest possible version of something that has already been tried.

The logic is identical every time

Strip out the logos and the play is the same in every case. A founder builds a beauty business — high margin, low inventory risk, a customer list that behaves like a fan club. Then comes the obvious next thought: if they will buy my lip gloss, they will buy my clothes.

Apparel is a different business. It is sizing and fit and returns and seasons and markdowns and warehouse space, and none of that shows up on a beauty P&L. The three headlines here describe Rhode entering that business in the most contained way available: per Hypebae, the brand's first piece of clothing, part of a navy capsule collection anchored by a windbreaker; per the Standard, Rhode moving beyond beauty with its first fashion launch; per Yahoo, a navy blue collection timed to Bieber's 30th birthday.

One category. One color story. One occasion. That is a birthday merch drop wearing a fashion label, and the distinction matters.

Rihanna, 2019: the ceiling

The closest precedent is Fenty. Rihanna's beauty launch proved a celebrity could build a legitimate cosmetics house rather than a licensing deal, and the follow-on was the most ambitious version of the apparel bet anyone has attempted: a full ready-to-wear maison under LVMH, with the group's own backing rather than a licensee's.

LVMH suspended it in 2021, roughly two years in. The lesson was not that Rihanna lacked reach — she had more than almost anyone. The lesson was that reach converts into lipstick far more easily than it converts into a wardrobe. Beauty is a repeat purchase with a low price of entry. Fashion is a considered purchase with a high cost of being wrong, and the customer has to want the garment, not just the founder.

Beyoncé, 2020: the shelf life

Ivy Park is the second data point and the more sobering one, because it actually worked at first. Launched with Topshop in 2016, relaunched with Adidas in 2020, it produced the thing celebrity apparel is supposed to produce: sellouts, headlines, a sense of momentum.

Then the momentum stopped being enough. Adidas and Beyoncé ended the partnership in 2024. Athletic wear is the most forgiving apparel category there is — no sizing complexity beyond the usual, no seasonal color risk worth speaking of, a customer who buys repeatedly — and even there, a name that could fill a first drop could not fill a fifth. A launch sells because of scarcity and attention. A line sells because of product. Those are different engines.

Kylie Jenner, 2021: the permission slip

Kylie Swim is the third and the most instructive for Rhode specifically, because it tested the exact assumption Rhode is now testing: that an audience built on one category will follow into another without being given a reason.

It launched in 2021 and drew immediate, widely reported complaints about fit and quality, then quietly stopped being part of the conversation. Jenner's cosmetics business had enormous reach and enormous goodwill. Neither transferred, because swimwear asks a customer to trust a brand with her body in a way lip liner never does.

Note what that means for a windbreaker. Outerwear is the one garment category where a beauty brand's credibility gap is narrowest — loose fit, forgiving sizing, one decision instead of a full look. It is the smartest possible first item. It is also the item most likely to sell out on novelty and tell Rhode nothing about whether it can make clothes.

What actually happened the last three times

In all three cases, the first drop worked and the second didn't. That is the pattern worth watching here, not the launch. Fenty had the full weight of LVMH and still could not hold. Ivy Park had sellouts and still lost its partner. Kylie Swim had the largest beauty audience in the world and still could not sell a second season.

The difference this time is structural rather than spiritual. Rhode is not building a fashion house. It is bolting a single item onto an existing beauty brand, tied to a personal milestone that guarantees press without requiring a runway budget. If it fails, it fails as an experiment, not as a division.

The tell is not this drop

Watch what happens after the windbreaker sells out — and it probably will. The question is whether Rhode restocks it, whether a second piece appears within a season, and whether that second piece is another outerwear item or an actual garment with a fit problem to solve.

One more season of navy is a merch program with good margins. A spring drop with a second category is a fashion business, and that is the one that has to clear the bar Fenty, Ivy Park and Kylie Swim all missed.

If you are buying, buy it as a jacket from a beauty brand and judge it on the return policy, the sizing chart and the fabric content — not on the birthday. And if you are just watching, skip the launch coverage entirely. Check back in six months and see whether Rhode is still making clothes, or whether the windbreaker became a collector's item for the same reason the others did.

Common questions

Is the Rhode windbreaker Hailey Bieber's first clothing item?

Yes. Hypebae describes it as Rhode's first piece of clothing, part of a navy capsule collection released for Bieber's 30th birthday. The London Evening Standard frames it as the brand moving beyond beauty with its first fashion launch, and Yahoo ties the navy drop to the birthday.

Why is Rhode launching only one clothing item instead of a full line?

Because the full-line version has already been tried and abandoned. Fenty's ready-to-wear house was suspended by LVMH in 2021, Beyoncé's Adidas partnership for Ivy Park ended in 2024, and Kylie Swim faded after its 2021 launch. A single outerwear piece limits inventory, sizing and markdown risk while still generating launch coverage.

What happened to Fenty, Ivy Park and Kylie Swim?

All three produced successful first drops and then failed to sustain. LVMH suspended Fenty's fashion line in 2021, roughly two years after launch. Adidas and Beyoncé ended the Ivy Park partnership in 2024. Kylie Swim, launched in 2021, drew widely reported complaints about fit and quality and did not become a recurring line.

What should I watch to know if Rhode's clothing push is real?

The second piece, not the first. A restock of the same windbreaker is a merch program. A new category within a season — something with an actual fit problem to solve — is the signal that Rhode intends to be an apparel business.

Related guides