counter hit make
Trending

Trending

Amen Thompson Is the Fourth Time the NBA Has Run This Experiment

4 min read

Everyone is searching. Almost nobody is reading past the headline.
Everyone is searching. Almost nobody is reading past the headline.

Amen Thompson's jump shot is not the most interesting thing about Amen Thompson. The clock is. Houston is running the fourth iteration of a test the NBA has already handed out three times, and the previous answers were: a championship, a teardown, and a trade demand.

Yahoo Sports made the affirmative case this week, placing him on its 25-under-25 list on the premise that he doesn't need a 3-point shot to be a star. That is a real argument, not a hot take. It is also, nearly word for word, the argument three other franchises made about three other players.

The Houston Chronicle asked a narrower question: which of the Rockets' early-season trends are real and which are fake? For Thompson specifically, history supplies the filter. Trends that survive are the ones that still work when the floor shrinks in April. Trends that don't are the ones that look great in November against a defense that isn't trying yet.

Boston built around the non-shooter and won

Rajon Rondo was a point guard who could not shoot from outside, in an era that still parked two big men in the paint. Boston's response was not to fix Rondo. It was to make his limitation irrelevant: Ray Allen and Paul Pierce on the wings, Eddie House and James Posey spotting up, Kevin Garnett behind everything. The 2008 Celtics won a title with a reluctant jump shooter running the offense, because the other four spots on the floor could shoot and the system leaned on defense, transition and cuts instead of half-court creation.

The lesson is not that non-shooters win titles. The lesson is that the supporting cast is the variable, not the jumper. Boston never asked Rondo to be something he wasn't. It hired a staff that designed an offense where he didn't have to be.

Philadelphia waited, and the asset became a problem

Ben Simmons was the cleanest test case the league has ever had: a 6-foot-10 ball handler with All-Defensive talent, elite open-floor speed and no jump shot. Philadelphia's plan was Houston's plan — the shot will come. It didn't. By the 2021 playoff loss to Atlanta, the conversation had shifted from he doesn't need a 3 to can he be on the floor in the last four minutes, which is a far worse conversation to be having about a max-contract player. The holdout, the trade to Brooklyn and the long fade followed.

What Philadelphia got wrong wasn't patience. It was the absence of a deadline. The franchise kept pricing Simmons as the player he might become, while the rest of the league started pricing him as the player he was. When those two numbers finally met, the gap was enormous, and the team ate it.

Toronto already ran the Fred VanVleet version

This is the one Raptors fans recognized instantly. Toronto spent VanVleet's last two seasons there pairing a small, ball-dominant guard with long, athletic forwards who couldn't shoot — Pascal Siakam, Scottie Barnes, OG Anunoby. The defense was excellent. The half-court offense was a clogged drain. The team lost the play-in game, VanVleet left for Houston in free agency, and within a year the roster had been dismantled around Barnes.

That is why the Raptors Rapture piece lands. Toronto audiences have already watched what happens when a good guard and a non-shooting wing share a floor and nobody on the staff solves the geometry. It looks fine for 44 minutes, and then the last four get ugly.

The difference in Houston is that the Rockets have the guard and the non-shooter on purpose, at the same time, while both are young enough to build around rather than break apart. That is either the smartest version of this experiment or the most expensive one.

What real or fake actually means here

Run the three precedents against the Chronicle's question and the filter is simple. A trend is real if it survives a set defense. Thompson's value in transition, on the offensive glass, as a cutter and as a defensive disruptor falls in the Rondo category. Those skills show up in a playoff series because none of them depend on the jumper.

A trend is fake if it depends on the opponent being disorganized. If Houston's half-court efficiency looks good because opposing teams are still learning their rotations in November, it will be gone in March. Philadelphia learned that. Toronto learned it twice.

The VanVleet precedent adds a front-office test on top of the on-court one. Toronto's mistake wasn't believing in its non-shooters. It was waiting until the roster's trade value had already peaked before deciding what to do about it.

What to watch

Ignore the three-point percentage. It is the least informative number attached to Thompson this season. Watch these instead:

  1. The last five minutes of close games against good defenses. Is Thompson the screener, the roller, the cutter — or is he standing in the corner? The first three are winning roles. The fourth is how Simmons ended up in Brooklyn.
  2. Whether VanVleet and Thompson share the floor in crunch time. Toronto's version of this failed because the spacing math never worked. If Houston's version holds, the staff has solved something the Raptors couldn't.
  3. How Houston talks about Thompson's next contract. This is the Philadelphia tell. A team that prices a non-shooter as a future shooter pays twice — once in salary, once in the trade return it never gets.

We have been here before. The good news for Houston is that here has produced a title once. The bad news is what it produced the other two times. In all three cases, the jump shot was never what decided it.

Common questions

Is the Ben Simmons comparison to Amen Thompson fair?

Only partly. Simmons was a primary ball handler asked to run a half-court offense, which is a heavier burden than Thompson carries in Houston. What transfers is the timeline problem: the longer a team prices a non-shooter as a future shooter, the smaller its options get. Yahoo Sports' argument is that Thompson's value doesn't hinge on the jumper, which is the case Philadelphia couldn't make by 2021.

What happened last time Fred VanVleet played next to a non-shooting wing?

Toronto paired VanVleet with long forwards like Pascal Siakam, Scottie Barnes and OG Anunoby. The defense held up, the half-court offense didn't, the team lost the play-in game, VanVleet left for Houston in free agency, and the roster was rebuilt around Barnes within a year. That's the pattern Raptors Rapture says Toronto fans recognize in Houston now.

Does Amen Thompson need a 3-point shot to be a star?

Yahoo Sports' 25-under-25 entry argues he does not, pointing to the rest of his game. The historical record says that's true only if the roster around him supplies the shooting and the coaching staff builds an offense that doesn't park him on the perimeter. Boston made that work with Rajon Rondo. Philadelphia didn't with Ben Simmons.

Which Rockets early-season trends should fans trust?

Use the playoff test the Houston Chronicle implies. Transition scoring, offensive rebounding and defensive disruption are real because they survive a set defense. Half-court efficiency built against disorganized November defenses is the kind of trend that evaporates by March.

Related guides